Our dinner trip to Caseus Fromagerie & Bistro in New Haven Friday cost me 120 miles’ worth of $4 gas and probably two weeks’ worth of calories and fat grams. And all I have to say is, WHY HAVEN’T I BEEN HERE SOONER.
The meal was a straight-up bacchanal of cheese and meat, save for a few shellfish cameos.
From carefully-selected cheese and charcuterie boards to venison meatloaf and gooey macaroni and cheese tossed with fresh lobster, we ate well. Very well.
One of the mix-ins for Caseus’ famed mac-and-cheese: sliced Kobe beef hot dogs. The guys decided they’d like one as a side dish, and asked if the kitchen could put it on a bun for them. “I’m not sure we have hot dog rolls, but maybe we can put it on brioche,” our waiter replied. Rob later deemed it “the best skinless hot dog I’ve ever eaten.”
Our beautiful cheese board, with an array of Italian cheeses. (I thought I took a picture of the list, but it’s nowhere to be found.) In an attempt to scrape up every last bit of the amazing strawberry-citrus preserves, pictured in the middle, Emily howled, “NOOOOO” when the waiter tried to take the board away.
Charcuterie heaven. Chicken liver mousse, pate, house-made sausage and prosciutto.
A Friday-night special: spicy, zesty day boat scallop ceviche topped with – yes, Manchego popcorn. We all tried a bite; it was a fresh-tasting departure from our heavy dishes.
Emily and I went with burgers – hers topped with extra-sharp cheddar, house-cured guanciale (bacon made from pig cheek) and fried duck egg. Mine was only slightly less decadent, with just guanciale. The burger was served on brioche with a huge pile of fantastically salty pommes frites and house-made mayonnaise. Medium-rare was perfect; red meat aficionados might even like it rare.
Venison meatloaf: a big plate of comfort. The meatloaf itself was topped with a ketchup glaze and served with a pile of velvety cheddar mashed potatoes, button mushrooms and roasted Brussels sprouts.
Most of us chose beer to wash down our plates of ecstasy. Caseus’ beer list is full of interesting brews, with lots of Belgian selections and some entries from Connecticut (Rob is a new fan of Woodbridge’s New England Brewing Company.)
Beyond its tremendous bistro (with a cavernous downstairs dining area full of nooks and crannies) Caseus also operates a “cheese truck” in downtown New Haven. The truck sells made-to-order grilled cheeses with customers’ choice of add-ons; tomato soup; salads; sausages and other treats.
Caseus, 93 Whitney Ave, New Haven. (203) 624-3373, caseusnewhaven.com.














Leeanne Griffin is a freelance writer and food enthusiast.