More experienced home cooks, and Italians who grew up in Nonna’s kitchen, are probably laughing at me right now. But they’re not going to dim my excitement. I MADE CHEESE.
On Friday night, we had dinner at Rizzuto’s in West Hartford, beginning our meal with a cheese plate. The selection of six cheeses featured their dreamy, fluffy, perfect housemade ricotta. We were in love, especially once we tasted it again with a touch of truffle honey.
On Saturday morning, I found myself flipping idly through a recent issue of Bon Appetit magazine, where I happened upon the page with Nancy Silverton’s DIY ricotta recipe. It was serendipitous, really. I decided I had to make it that night.
The recipe calls for whole milk and cream; I just went with five cups of whole milk. It boiled over quickly – nearly ruining a burner on our flat top stove – but produced a decent amount of curd after settling for 15 minutes. I drained the first batch, reboiled the milk again with a little more lemon juice and then drained the (middling) curds from the second round.
The yield, after about an hour’s worth of drain time? Maybe a cup and a half of ricotta. It’s certainly not a high-volume recipe. But if you’re prioritizing freshness and taste over convenience, this is the way to go. It was really excellent, and you can’t beat the pride factor of making your own cheese, especially when it’s so delicious.
We ate our ricotta in the form of bruschetta, with oven-roasted tomatoes and fresh basil that we’d picked ourselves at Easy Pickin’s Orchard. The rest of our farm spoils included baby eggplants, leeks and Macoun and Gala apples. Next summer might just be the year we splurge on that CSA.